McDavid Creates Challenges For Referees | Oilersnetwork.com - Edmonton Oilers News and Rumours

McDavid Creates Challenges For Referees

McDavid isn't just a special player when it comes to fans. His speed, skill and leadership draws the attention of opposing players and coaches. Coaches like Bruce Boudreau, Ken Hitchcock and Mike Babcock have all praised his performances and admired what he brings to the Edmonton Oilers. Some have publicly come out and thanked their lucky stars that McDavid didn't have a better performance when playing against their team.


Something is going on the NHL and for Edmonton Oilers fans, it's something they're starting to get frustrated with. McDavid has been the topic of a few debates, most of them centered around the fact that calls from the referees are not going his way.


The Rules

Some will call it whining when fans complain that their players aren't getting the calls. In this case, fans aren't asking for special treatment. Most are simply calling for the rules to be called as they're written. Lately, that hasn't been the case.

Take for example the Oilers recent game against St. Louis. The Oilers ended up squeaking out a victory — winning in overtime — but prior to getting there, McDavid had a breakaway in which it's clear that there were at least two slashes and one potential hook by Alex Pietrangelo. No call of any kind was awarded to McDavid and the Oilers and it was obvious if not a penalty, the argument could have been made McDavid should have been awarded a penalty shot.

The non-call by the referees in that situation was embarrassing for the NHL. I'm sure the league doesn't want its officials blowing calls so badly. Doing so limits scoring, it detracts from things like penalty shots, which is great for the league and overall it simply unfair to a team that could have lost the game with a bounce that might have gone the wrong way later in the game.

Edmonton Oilers' Connor McDavid (97) bleeds from the lip after a high stick (Jason Franson/CP)


Why Did It Happen?

The question is, why does something like this happen? How does a play so clearly a penalty get missed by the referees when anyone, even those in the nosebleeds, can see the infraction? My take is pretty simple and it's the same as some with a lot more inside hockey knowledge than I.

Connor McDavid is so dynamic and fun to watch, that not only do players, coaches and fans get caught bewildered by his talent, so do the referees. David Staples put a sample of some of the most egregious plays against McDavid that resulted in no call.

Sometimes when you have a player who can do one hundred things 99 percent of the rest of league can't do, people want to see how the play ends up. When McDavid was on a breakaway in this situation, is it possible that the ref Chris Lee didn't make the call because he wanted to see if McDavid could fight off the play and score anyways? I think that's not only possible; but probable.

NHL Superstars


McDavid isn't the only player in the NHL that might have this issue. The league is full of young talent now that has skills like never before. Auston Matthews, Johhny Gaudreau and others make the life of a referee more difficult.

Should these stars get calls that other players don't get because, by the nature of their talent, they'll draw more penalties? There has always been an unwritten rule that the "new guys" don't get the calls the veterans do. They haven't earned the trust of the refs. Would calling so many penalties be looked at as a bias for the young stars that are now dominating the game?

The argument is that not calling these penalties hurts the NHL. This is a league that badly wants its stars to shine. Players like McDavid are a major reason the NHL is so profitable. Not calling these obvious penalties hurts the excitement of the game.

The Answer


The NHL needs to have a conference with its referees and simply remind them to call the game by the rules. Don't give advantages to superstars because they are superstars. At the same time, don't avoid making a call because the superstar has more talent and can fight through more than the average player.

Most importantly, when you're officiating a game where one of the best players in the game is part of the contest, don't get caught watching how dynamic he is. Understand that at least once or twice in a game a player like McDavid will "wow" everyone in the building. As a referee, you have to take awe in that moment after the play has ended and not during. Referees are human and sometimes what McDavid can do seems inhuman. Still, refs need to stay grounded and remember a rule is a rule no matter who it's called for or against.

But, who cares what I think right? For now, I'll just keep my mouth shut until I feel like spilling my guts again.





Jim Parsons is a business owner, husband, father and sports fan. For more information about Oilersnetwork.com founder and Oil Spill articles author Jim Parsons, click here.




Want to start spilling your sports gut? We're looking for writers. Go here.





10 Responses to "McDavid Creates Challenges For Referees"

  1. Great article - if the refs could ever make the calls the rulebook tells them they should, it'd be fun to watch these superstars again. As it is, they lesser talented players just "slow" them down and get away with it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree - the fact that the young stars are so good means that they should have every chance - drawing penalties is a good part of the game, and it should be appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well Jim I have been following your comments for a few months now and the first time I have responded. You are spot on your analysis of what has been going on regarding the recent non-calls against McDavid. Keep up the good work. Enjoying reading your comments.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Appreciate the kind words. I do think the NHL will say something and there will come a time where the refs make too many calls. But, over time it always works itself out to the fact that a lot of stars wind up with a negative reputation because the my have to beg for calls

      Delete
  4. UFC puts out TUF 26 throwing call for three weight classes. The UFC issued a throwing call Wednesday for contenders in three weight classes for the most recent period of the FS1-communicated arrangement: ladies. 'TUF 26' tryouts slated for May 23; male and female UFC hopefuls. UFC on FOX 24's "Jacare" Souza won't down from unsafe battles. RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil – Ronaldo Souza wasn't shocked when the UFC reacted to his demand for a battle with the name of rising.
    UFC 210
    UFC 210 Live , UFC 210 Fight Card , UFC 210 Fight , UFC 210 Card , UFC 210 Live Stream , UFC 210 PPV



    Two years into UFC title rule, Daniel Cormier as yet battling for regard Meanwhile, after a long keep running as the prevalent belt in the UFC, light ... Daniel Cormier, the current UFC light heavyweight champion, is set to. UFC 210 early say something comes about and live video stream (9 am ET Predictions for each battle on the UFC 210: Cormier versus Johnson 2. UFC 210 Odds And Best Bets For The Biggest Fights And Bonuses.
    UFC 210
    UFC 210 Live , UFC 210 Fight Card , UFC 210 Fight , UFC 210 Card , UFC 210 Live Stream , UFC 210 PPV

    ReplyDelete
  5. The 101st Indianapolis 500 will be the sixth round of the 2017 Verizon” IndyCar Series season” and the 22nd sanctioned aspart of the Indy Racing League/IndyCar Series. There have been five different winners in the first five races leading up to the Indianapolis 500. The season began March 12 at St. Petersburg, with Sébastien Bourdais a surprise winner.


    2017 Indianapolis 500

    Indianapolis 500 Live

    Watch Indianapolis 500

    Indianapolis 500 Stream

    Indianapolis 500 Online

    Indianapolis 500 Race

    Indianapolis 500 Drivers

    Indy 500

    2017 Indy 500

    Indy 500 Live

    Watch Indy 500

    Indy 500 Live Stream

    Indianapolis 500 Start Time

    Indianapolis 500 TV Coverage

    ReplyDelete